Thoughts about reviews and reviewing

Image result for 5 stars

It’s hard trying to decide what book to read, you read the blurb and the first few pages -stare at the cover for a while- and sometimes it grips you and your decision is easy and sometimes it’s not. So it’s helpful to read reviews and see what others thought before you decide to make a purchase and sit down for some time with this book. (Yeah, you know this already you’re reading a book review blog)

This is where it can get tricky! I’ve been put off reading books because of the negative reviews. I didn’t read Discovery of Witches for a while because I read the reviews of people saying why they didn’t like it. I didn’t want to start reading and end up reading something I don’t enjoy. But I kept hearing about it and in the end I read it and loved it! I went on to read the other books in the All Souls Trilogy and this is my third time rereading it at the moment. And I am excited for the tv series!

A Discovery of Witches: Soon to be a major TV series (All Souls 1) (All Souls Trilogy) by [Harkness, Deborah]

Completely the opposite: I read some amazing reviews for some books and started to read them and then realised after reading a few pages/chapters that I didn’t enjoy the book and could not understand why everyone else was giving it such amazing reviews. It’s so frustrating starting a book and then realising it’s not something you’re going to enjoy.

Everyone is different. And what we enjoy at one point we might not enjoy another time, sometimes I like to read fat books with a long story, description and atmosphere, literary fiction or general fiction:  Kate Riordan, Carlos Ruiz Zafon, Kate Morton to name a few writers who write gripping and immersive novels. I like to read stories with detail about the characters, where you get to know them, like A Discovery of Witches. Other times I need a change and I’ll read something completely different. After you’ve read so many of the same genre for a while you need a break, so right now  I’m reading Raven Black by Anne Cleeves, I don’t usually read crime but I’m riveted.

I prefer books by the writers I’ve mentioned and Discovery of Witches to fast paced thrillers, where the sentences are shorter and the book is over within a day or so because you have to find out what happens next, I find some of these books exhausting to read but I do enjoy them don’t get me wrong. I loved Did you see Melody? by Sophie Hannah 

But then some of the people who wrote the negative reviews for A Discovery of Witches may prefer faster paced stories and that might be why they wrote the bad reviews. So you can’t really rely on reviews to decide to read a book and you can’t really rely on reading the first few pages.

Yes, I just admitted that on my review blog!

All you can do is take a chance. Try a book for yourself. Tell others what you think. I review books to share my views and get the word out about books I love. I tend to read more reviews on blogs now they seem more reliable than the one sentence reviews on merchant sites.


And there’s one thing that I can’t stand and that I will not do. I hate it when people go through a book and tear it apart point by point in their review. They didn’t like the book so they write a scathing review which may seem constructive to them but all they’re doing is criticising and putting it down. Book bullies! By all means say why you didn’t like a book but I don’t think people have to be so horrible about it, after all someone wrote that book, they actually spent months and months writing and editing it, (even the stinkers) and some people may love that book! I have read one of these type of reviews for my favourite book and I responded to it which was not a good idea, this reviewer in question wrote lovely reviews for some books but when she wrote negative reviews she seemed to change. She swore in her reviews and she basically attacked the book!

I will always give an honest review. I don’t always write bad reviews, it’s easier to leave negative reviews and be harsh on merchant websites but when you have a blog you don’t really want to be overly negative about peoples work. Maybe it’s because being a writer myself I feel for them. (maybe it’s just me, maybe I’m too nice) Even though badly written books make me so angry (it’s my opinion, just my opinion) there’s books out there that haven’t been published or are not that popular that are amazing but then books that are published that are absolutely terrible. But that’s another point entirely I guess.

To get to the point: I love reading reviews to decide what to read next but I like to make up my own mind too. I love reading reviews on blogs just for their own sake. I love sharing my love for books and finding out what others enjoy.

Have you ever read and enjoyed a book that had negative reviews? Or vice versa, tell us in the comments 🙂




7 thoughts on “Thoughts about reviews and reviewing”

  1. I always try to say at least one good thing about a book, even if I didn’t like it because there’s bound to be at least one thing that kept me going! I try to think of it as a lot of time and resources went into making it so I wouldn’t want to bash it

    Liked by 1 person

  2. It’s so hard to go by reviews sometimes. I usually find some books that are getting a lot of positive reviews then I ask my sister what she thinks of the book. If she says I’ll like it that’s my gauge because she knows my taste pretty well. Haven’t read a book with a bad review that I’ve liked but I have read a book that had good reviews that I didn’t like that much. Everyone’s taste is so different so it’s hard 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I feel like reviews are great and a good starting block, but at the end of the day we SHOULD always read what we want, right?! And I always find reviews most helpful if I know I have similar taste to the reviewer. Like we are all sooo different, so I find my “bookish twins” and when we match opinions on a lot of books, I start to really trust their reviews, because I know they suit my tastes! And I don’t mind negative or harsh reviews, 😂 although I always get offended if I see one on my favourite book lmao. I mean, it’s obvious we’re not all going to agree?! But it’s hard to see your favourite book being chewed out. I just never comment. 😉 😂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. So true but I have to stop myself. I haven’t found someone with similar taste as me yet. A lot of blogs I follow mention books and authors I don’t know but it keeps me well read and I love reading blogs.


  4. I am all for slower paced books but I need to get something out of it (especially character wise)and A Discovery of Witches was not that for me. The romance was a big no for me. 😀
    But I agree that you do need to take reading negative reviews with a grain of salt sometimes.We aren’t all going to like the same things.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.